A name on title does not always decide who owns an investment property. In Harris v. Melo, 2026 ONCA 798, the Court of Appeal held that the ten-year period had not started while the paying partner kept collecting the rent.
This is a civil co-ownership decision, not a divorce case, and we explain below where it may, and may not, matter for separating partners in Dufferin County.
In This Guide
The case facts and result; what a resulting trust can mean when one partner paid; how section 5(1) affected the limitation period; practical record-keeping steps; local contact information and common questions.
Quick Facts
What case is this?
Harris v. Melo, 2026 ONCA 798.
Which court decided it?
The Ontario Court of Appeal.
When was the decision released?
November 9, 2026.
What was the result?
The appeal was allowed. The Court declared the appellant beneficial owner of the respondent’s 50% interest. That declaration governs how the sale proceeds are distributed.
What is the key point?
A co-owner’s name on title, without a financial contribution, did not defeat the resulting-trust presumption on these facts. The ten-year limitation period may not start while the claimant remains in possession or continues receiving the property’s profits.
Where is OMNI LAW GROUP?
OMNI LAW GROUP
162 Broadway, Suite 8
Orangeville, ON L9W 1K3
905-497-7200
Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
What happened in Harris v. Melo?
The parties were not married. They bought an investment property in 1989 and were registered as tenants in common, each with a 50% interest. No matrimonial home was at issue. Their relationship ended in 1990. The published reasons deal with property law and a limitation period, not with spousal or parenting claims, and this post treats the decision on that basis.
One party supplied the full down payment and paid the mortgage and upkeep. The other party was added to title to replace an original co-purchaser who was unavailable. The property was managed and rented over the following 35 years.
The co-owner who had not paid applied for partition and sale. The co-owner who had paid counter-applied for a declaration that the other held their 50% interest in trust for him, making him the property’s 100% beneficial owner.
The application judge dismissed that claim as outside the ten-year period in section 4 of Ontario’s Real Property Limitations Act (RPLA). The judge found the claimant knew by 1995 at the latest that the other party claimed beneficial ownership. The judge also found the claimant would have succeeded on the merits. The property was ordered sold.
The Ontario Court of Appeal allowed the appeal. The property had already sold, so the Court’s declaration governs how the sale proceeds are distributed. The respondent was ordered to pay $22,500 in appeal costs and $28,445.85 in reversed application costs.
Does a name on title prove beneficial ownership?
Not always. Harris v. Melo considered the purchase-money resulting-trust presumption. In practical terms, the Court’s unrebutted finding meant the person who supplied the purchase money was the beneficial owner of the other party’s 50% interest.
The case’s consumer takeaway is that a partner’s name on title, including as a co-signer, does not by itself defeat the presumption when that partner made no financial contribution. The result still depends on the evidence and the particular facts. The presumption is rebuttable. A person named on title can answer a resulting-trust claim with evidence that the paying party intended a gift or a loan, and the court weighs that evidence against the circumstances of the purchase. The Court’s decision does not mean that every common-law partner property dispute will have the same outcome.
For readers researching common-law partner property in Ontario, a distinction matters: legal title records registered ownership, while a resulting-trust claim concerns beneficial ownership. In Harris v. Melo, the parties were tenants in common in Ontario, but the resulting-trust finding determined who beneficially owned the disputed share. That distinction comes up in an Orangeville family law consultation too, because the same question of who really paid can surface when common-law partners separate and divide an investment property.
The case involved an investment property, not a matrimonial home. Matrimonial-home rules differ. This decision should not be treated as a guide to the division or possession of a matrimonial home. For how those separate rules work on a rural property, see our post on the matrimonial home deduction on rural acreage.
When can the ten-year limitation period start?
Section 4 of the RPLA sets a ten-year period for certain claims involving recovery of land or rent. But section 5(1) postpones when that period begins for a claimant who has been in possession of the land or receiving its profits.
The Court held that the limitation period had not started because the claimant had not been dispossessed and had not discontinued receiving the property’s profits. It followed Waterstone Properties Corporation v. Caledon (Town), 2017 ONCA 623.
The Court also rejected the argument that section 5(1) protects only people without legal title who are claiming through adverse possession. The provision applied to the claim before it. The result was that the ten-year clock had not begun to run.
This is a limitation issue, not a general exemption from limitation periods. A dispute about common-law separation property rights in Orangeville or elsewhere in Ontario can turn on the specific claim, possession history, income from the property, and evidence. If rent was collected by one person for years, the records of who received it and when may matter as much as the deed.
What can separated partners take from this case?
First, a name on title does not settle every question about who beneficially owns a property. The Court’s resulting-trust finding mattered because one party had paid the purchase-related costs and the other had not contributed financially.
Second, the ten-year RPLA period may not start while the claimant remains in possession or continues receiving the property’s profits. That is a fact-specific application of section 5(1), not a general rule that time never runs for co-owners.
Third, a titled partner who wants the limitation period to run needs to consider the statutory events identified in section 5(1), including actual dispossession or discontinuance of receipt of profits. The case does not establish that a particular step will produce a particular outcome in another dispute.
Fourth, document contributions and intentions when buying. Keep records of down payments, mortgage payments, upkeep, rental income and the parties’ understanding of ownership. A cohabitation agreement in Orangeville may also be a way for partners to record their arrangements. The facts and wording matter.
For a possible partition and sale in Ontario, records about title, contributions, possession, rental income and communications may all be relevant. A lawyer can review the documents and explain how the issues might apply to a specific matter.
Local information for Orangeville and Peel
OMNI LAW GROUP’s Orangeville office is at 162 Broadway, Suite 8. The Orangeville Courthouse is at 10 Louisa Street. The A. Grenville & William Davis Courthouse is at 7755 Hurontario Street in Brampton. These are local reference points only. Harris v. Melo is not attributed here to either courthouse.
OMNI LAW GROUP serves Orangeville and Dufferin County from its Orangeville base, and serves Brampton and Peel Region from that same base. There is no current Brampton office. Peel family matters are heard at the A. Grenville & William Davis Courthouse in Brampton, while preparation and document signing happen in Orangeville or by virtual appointment.
For questions about co-ownership after separation, contact OMNI LAW GROUP at 905-497-7200. A conflict check is required before the firm can discuss whether it can act.
Initial Consultation (20 Minutes): A scheduled 20-minute initial meeting to discuss your matter and confirm whether we can act. Subject to a conflict check. No legal advice is provided and no solicitor-client relationship is created until a retainer is confirmed.
Local services
For family-law questions, see our Family Lawyer in Brampton service page. For criminal-law matters, see our Criminal Defence Lawyer in Orangeville service page.
Local Legal FAQ
Does a partner’s name on title always mean they own half the property beneficially?
No. Harris v. Melo shows that legal title and beneficial ownership can differ. The Court applied an unrebutted purchase-money resulting-trust finding and declared the appellant beneficial owner of the respondent’s 50% interest. The case’s facts included one party providing the full down payment and paying the mortgage and upkeep, while the other was added to title without a financial contribution. The decision does not determine every co-ownership dispute. The documents, financial contributions, intentions and other evidence in each matter may affect the analysis.
When does the ten-year limitation period start for a property claim?
In Harris v. Melo, the Court applied section 5(1) of the RPLA. It held that the ten-year period had not begun because the claimant had not been dispossessed and had not discontinued receiving the property’s profits. The Court rejected the argument that section 5(1) applies only to claimants without legal title. The decision does not mean that the limitation period will always be postponed in a co-ownership dispute. The facts about possession and receipt of profits matter, and the result should not be assumed without reviewing the particular claim.
Does this case apply to a matrimonial home?
The property in Harris v. Melo was an investment property, not a matrimonial home. Matrimonial-home rules differ, so the decision should not be treated as deciding how a matrimonial home is divided or who may possess it. It addressed a resulting-trust claim and the timing of a limitation period under the RPLA in the circumstances before the Court. A person dealing with a matrimonial home or another property after separation should have the relevant title, payment and ownership records reviewed in light of the specific facts.
Contact OMNI LAW GROUP
WE HANDLE CASES AT THE A. GRENVILLE & WILLIAM DAVIS COURTHOUSE IN BRAMPTON AND AT 10 LOUISA ST. IN ORANGEVILLE.
WE FOCUS ON THE INTERSECTION OF CRIMINAL DEFENCE & FAMILY LAW.
For common-law property, resulting-trust or co-ownership questions after separation, contact OMNI LAW GROUP at 905-497-7200. A conflict check is required before the firm can discuss whether it can act.
Where family and criminal matters overlap, separate retainers may be required.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. It does not create a solicitor-client relationship.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Vaneet Sangha is Co-founder of OMNI LAW GROUP and a member of the Law Society of Ontario. OMNI LAW GROUP's Orangeville office is at 162 Broadway, Suite 8, Orangeville, ON L9W 1K3. Call 905-497-7200. Business hours are Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM.